Skip to content

The $200k House Challenge

The $200k House Challenge published on 6 Comments on The $200k House Challenge

You have $200k to spend on a home within 2 hours of NYC, including renovations. Where would you look?

As mentioned before, I’m in search of a flip. I could put myself into debt for a year and not be able to afford pet food or even human food but I’d rather not, so I’m sticking to a budget of $200k. Yeah, I know. It ain’t gonna be in Brooklyn. Not even split with a partner. Not even a one bedroom apartment in a fringe neighborhood.

After searching for about a month, here’s what I’ve learned…

You want to own a home in the boroughs for $200k? It’s possible. There are homes in crappy parts of Bushwick, Jamaica and East New York. Actually, pretty difficult to come by houses for under $300k, but short sales exist. If you’re purchasing a short sale, be prepared to have it drag on for close to a year.

Saw a couple of listings out on The Island. Riverhead and Central Islip. A friend from The Island wasn’t too impressed with those locations. Saw quite a few listings in Jersey City and Newark, especially Newark. No, the JC listings were not prime JC.

So, what’s the best bet for finding a home for under $200k (Oh, did I mention that INCLUDES renovations?)? Upstate. Whether it be commuter location or second home, the houses exist. Saw a bunch in Rhinebeck and one in Hyde Park that I may put an offer on, but it will only be back up as someone got to it first. Bastards.

Today I’m heading up to Warwick. That’s a commuter area and there are about 4-5 listings to look at. It’s promising.

So, you want a house on a small budget? You can do it. As long as you’re not a whiny douche like this guy.

6 Comments

We came to a similar conclusion…after realizing that we couldn’t afford the kind of place we wanted in city. We had a budget of $275 and found a great place in Fishkill. We did see a number of decent options in Hyde Park in the $200 range.

Hi,

Sal Siggia here from Brooklyn Flea. (amy’s friend). I think anything by the ocean in Bklyn / Queens is interesting and potentially flippable.
Upstate – forget the “2 hours from NY” rule. An extra 1/2 hour drive to Western Sullivan or even Delaware counties have great values right now. I’m in Cochecton and my shop is in Callicoon. Lots of properties in 100k range with river views, property and scenic settings. Come visit – i’ll show you around.

Primary Sidebar